Electric bicycles rely on either a cadence sensor or a torque sensor to detect rider pedaling and activate motor assistance. While both systems manage pedal assist (PAS), they measure entirely different mechanical inputs and rely on different electrical architectures. When pedal assist fails, understanding whether your bike uses a cadence or torque sensor determines what tools you need, what symptoms to look for, and how difficult the repair will be.
Key Differences Between Torque and Cadence Sensor Failures
Cadence sensor failures cause an “all-or-nothing” outage where the motor completely fails to turn on during pedaling, usually caused by a misaligned or missing magnetic disc on the bottom bracket. Torque sensor failures produce subtle drivability faults—such as weak power, surging, delayed response, or motor run-on—usually caused by zero-point calibration drift, bottom bracket play, or strain-gauge wear.
Mechanical and Operational Differences
To diagnose pedal assist issues accurately, you must first recognize the fundamental operating differences between the two sensor types:
[Cadence Sensor] ──► Detects Crank Rotation Speed (RPM) ──► Digital On/Off Pulses (Magnets)
[Torque Sensor] ──► Detects Pedal Force / Pressure (Nm) ─► Dynamic Analog Voltage (Strain Gauge)
- Cadence Sensors: These measure only how fast the crank arms turn. The system uses a ring of magnets passing by a stationary pickup. As long as the pedals rotate forward, the controller delivers power based on your selected display assist level (PAS 1–5), regardless of how hard you push.
- Torque Sensors: These measure how hard you push down on the pedals. Using an integrated strain gauge or magnetic torsion core inside the bottom bracket or motor axle, the sensor measures microscopic flex in the metal. The controller multiplies your human effort in real time, delivering more power when you push hard on hills and tapering off as your effort drops.
Failure Symptom Comparison
Because each sensor uses a completely different sensing mechanism, their failure symptoms vary significantly:
| Failure Characteristic | Cadence Sensor Failure | Torque Sensor Failure |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Symptom | Complete loss of pedal assist; motor will not engage when pedaling. | Motor assists weakly, surges erratically, or provides uneven power. |
| Throttle Function | Throttle usually works normally while pedal assist is dead. | Throttle usually works normally while pedal assist is uneven or dead. |
| Motor Run-On (Ghost Power) | Rarely causes run-on unless the sensor chip shorts high. | Common; motor keeps pushing after pedaling stops due to voltage drift. |
| Speed/Cadence Sensitivity | Failure is binary: works completely or not at all. | Power fluctuates depending on pedaling angle or downstroke pressure. |
| Display Error Codes | Seldom triggers error codes; controller simply thinks you stopped pedaling. | Frequently triggers dedicated sensor error codes on proprietary drives. |
| Physical Vulnerability | External plastic disc slides, wobbles, or collects iron grime. | Internal bearings wear out, lockrings loosen, or cables pinch internally. |
For troubleshooting specific to cadence systems, see E-Bike Cadence Sensor Failure: Pedal Assist Not Engaging. If your torque-assist bike feels weak or unresponsive, review E-Bike Torque Sensor Failure: Sluggish or No Assistance.
Diagnostic Trees: Which Sensor Failed?
Cadence Sensor Diagnostic Tree
Because most cadence sensors sit outside the frame on the crank spindle, failures are almost always physical or visual:
Cadence System Fails (Throttle Works, PAS Dead)
│
▼
Is the magnet disc spinning with the crank arm?
├── NO ──► Plastic ring is slipping on spindle; press back into spline / tighten ring.
└── YES ──► Check air gap between disc and pickup.
├── Gap > 3mm? ──► Slide disc closer (1-2mm from sensor).
└── Gap is OK? ──► Check sensor LED / test 5V supply and ground wires.
If individual magnets have fallen out of the plastic disc or the air gap has widened from trail vibration, the pickup simply stops registering crank rotation.
Torque Sensor Diagnostic Tree
Torque sensors are typically sealed inside the bottom bracket cartridge or integrated into a mid-drive motor casing. Visual inspection is rarely enough; diagnosis focuses on baseline calibration and signal output:
Torque System Malfunctions (Weak, Surging, or Dead)
│
▼
Perform Zero-Point Baseline Reset (Power cycle display with feet off pedals)
├── Solved? ──► Sensor had established a false load baseline during startup.
└── Failed? ──► Check for bottom bracket play or physical binding.
│
├── Wiggle crankarms: Lateral play detected?
│ └── Fix loose bottom bracket cups / replace worn spindle bearings.
└── Spindle is tight: Test analog signal voltage with multimeter.
├── Voltage stuck at baseline under load? ──► Strain gauge failure.
└── Resting voltage drifts above 1.5V? ────► Zero-point sensor failure.
If your torque sensor is surging unpredictably under foot pressure, see Solving E-Bike Torque Sensor Calibration and Response Problems.
Multimeter Testing: Digital Pulses vs. Analog Voltage
When you hook up a digital multimeter to test sensor output, the readings look fundamentally different:
- Testing a Cadence Sensor: Set your meter to DC volts. Connect the black probe to Ground and the red probe to the Signal wire. As you turn the crank slowly forward, the meter will toggle cleanly between 0.0V and 5.0V every time a magnet sweeps past the sensor face. If the voltage stays flatlined at 0V or 5V while turning the cranks, the Hall chip is dead.
- Testing a Torque Sensor: Connect your meter across Ground and Signal. At rest, the meter should show a steady baseline voltage (typically between 0.7V and 1.0V). When you stand on a pedal with the brakes locked, the reading should smoothly scale upward to between 3.0V and 4.2V in direct proportion to your foot force. If the reading never changes when you put your weight on the pedal, the internal strain gauge has separated or lost connection.
Repair Difficulty and Replacement Realities
The physical design of each sensor directly impacts how easy it is to repair:
- Cadence Sensors: Very easy and inexpensive to repair. Most external cadence discs and pickups can be replaced in minutes using a standard bicycle crank puller tool. Replacement sensors are widely available and typically use standardized 3-pin Julet or JST connectors.
- Torque Sensors: Significantly more involved and expensive. Replacing a torque sensor usually requires pulling both crank arms, removing the entire bottom bracket cartridge with specialized spline tools, and routing internal wires through the frame to the controller. On closed mid-drive systems (such as Bosch, Shimano, or Brose), the torque sensor is an integrated, non-serviceable internal component. If the internal strain gauge fails on these platforms, the motor must be serviced by a specialist or replaced as a complete assembly.
If your pedal assist remains non-functional after evaluating both sensor types, widen your search to check brake cutoffs and harness plugs using our comprehensive guide on Troubleshooting E-Bike Pedal Assist (PAS) Sensor Failures.